Should the Mets sign Justin Verlander?

Justin Verlander /

Let’s get this out of the method initially…

Justin Verlander is 39 years of ages. He’ll turn 40 on February 20, simply over a month prior to the 2023 MLB season begins.

The Mets currently have Max Scherzer, who will start next season at 38 years of ages and turn 39 on July 27.

Would it be perfect to have a 40-year-old and a 39-year-old at the top of the Mets’ rotation as they try to win a World Series, which would naturally need both Verlander and Scherzer pitching deep into October and perhaps into November? Perhaps not.

But Verlander isn’t simply some other soon-to-be-40-year-old pitcher. He’s among the very best pitchers of the last twenty years and is still at the top of his video game.

And that’s why we will talk about the advantages and disadvantages of the Mets signing him…


As kept in mind above, Verlander’s age ought to by no methods disqualify him from being thought about by the Mets — vice versa. But it still needs to be talked about.

The primary issue for any group need to be the general mileage on Verlander’s arm, which has actually logged 3,163 innings over 482 starts covering 17 seasons given that he debuted with the Detroit Tigers in 2005.

At some point, Verlander’s age will overtake him. But in his mind, he is no place near to done being a threat on the mound. Back in 2018, Verlander stated he was believing he may pitch up until he’s 45. That would be the 2028 season. Is that sensible? Perhaps not. But all the Mets or any other group ought to appreciate is the next season or more.

Verlander had perhaps the very best season of his profession in 2022 (which we’ll enter listed below), however there were some indication late. 

Justin Verlander

Justin Verlander / Troy Taormina – U.S.A. TODAY Sports

The very first problem was a calf injury that kept Verlander out of action from Aug. 29 to Sept. 15. That’s reasonably small in the grand plan of things, however still noteworthy.

Then in the playoffs, with the Houston Astros on their march towards an ultimate World Series title, Verlander stumbled two times in 4 starts. He enabled 6 work on 10 hits in 4 innings in Game 1 of the ALDS versus the Seattle Mariners, and after that blew a 5-0 lead in Game 1 of the World Series versus the Philadelphia Phillies, permitting 5 work on 6 hits in 5 innings.

But Verlander was dominant in Game 1 of the ALCS versus the Yankees (he enabled one operate on 3 hits while strolling one and setting out 11 in 6 innings) and gutted it out in Game 5 of the World Series, permitting one operate on 4 hits while strolling 4 and setting out 6 in 5 innings.

Could Verlander’s 2 postseason cars suggest his age? Maybe. Or it might have simply been a pitcher using down at the very end of the season in his very first year back from Tommy John surgical treatment, after tossing absolutely no innings in 2021 and simply 6 innings in 2020.

Another problem when it concerns Verlander is the cash and years he’ll get — perhaps a one-or two-year offer worth around $40 million each year. But if the Mets want to pay Jacob deGrom around $35 million or $40 million each year for 3 years (and all signs are that they are), it stands to factor that they’d want to provide a couple of years to Verlander.

It is at this point that we’ll keep in mind that the Mets need to certainly just pursue Verlander if they lose deGrom. There is no world where it makes good sense for the Mets to have $120 million or two bound in 3 aces who are 34 or older. But if deGrom goes, there’s a simple case to be made that Verlander need to be at the top of the Mets’ list to change him.


Verlander is an ace coming off perhaps the very best season of his profession.

I’ve seen individuals make the case that the Mets having Verlander atop the rotation with Scherzer would just be too dangerous due to the fact that of their age. But a few of those exact same individuals would be simply great if the Mets had deGrom atop the rotation once again or signed Carlos Rodon rather. And it’s difficult to make an argument that Verlander is a larger injury dangerous than either of them, in spite of his age.

Jacob deGrom

Jacob deGrom / Wendell Cruz – U.S.A. TODAY Sports

Maybe deGrom, who missed out on the 2nd half of the 2021 season and the very first half of the 2022 season — and whose things decreased as 2022 endured — is past the lots of injury concerns that have actually hindered him recently. But possibly he’s not.

As far as Rodon, he has actually pitched more than 133 innings simply two times in his profession, and handled shoulder concerns that affected completion of his season in 2021 — a year where he tossed 132.2 innings.

It need to likewise be kept in mind that Rodon has actually had simply 2 elite seasons — and they came after he was average for the very first 6 seasons of his profession. Maybe he’s discovered a method to preserve his supremacy and he’ll be the image of health moving forward. But I would not bank on both of those things holding true.

I would rather bank on Verlander, and I type of currently have, given that I forecasted prior to the 2022 season that he would win the American League Cy Young award, which will be formally offered to him quickly.

In 2022, Verlander was nearly incredibly excellent, leading the league in age (1.75), WHIP (0.829), PERIOD+ (220), and strikes per 9 (6.0).

Verlander’s things in his very first year back from TJS was still nasty — his fastball balanced 95.1 miles per hour (it was 94.9 miles per hour prior to TJS and 95.2 miles per hour back in 2017), and he called it approximately the high-90s when required. Meanwhile, his slider, curve, and changeup were right where they have actually constantly remained in regards to typical speed. Verlander’s advanced statistics were likewise exceptionally excellent, so what he carried out in 2022 was not a mirage.

It’s likewise reasonable to argue that Verlander missing out on the majority of 2020 and all of 2021 due to TJS might benefit him over the next season or more, given that he does not have 2 seasons of additional mileage on his arm.

Justin Verlander

Justin Verlander / Troy Taormina – U.S.A. TODAY Sports

Like Scherzer, Verlander is a bulldog on the mound and among the most extreme rivals in baseball. That would play well in New York on a win-now group.

Unlike Rodon, Verlander will not be connected to the 1 year certifying deal. If the Mets sign a gamer who gets and declines the QO, they lose their leading second-round and fifth-round choices in the 2023 MLB Draft, and lose $1 countless worldwide benefit cash. That’s a huge offer.


For one, Verlander can likely be had for a couple of years while deGrom will most likely get 3 or 4 and Rodon may get 5.

And in spite of Verlander’s age, calling him a huge injury danger is type of silly. Verlander tossed 206 innings in 2017, followed by 214 in 2018, 223 in 2019, and 175 in 2022 in his very first season back from TJS.

Could Verlander get injured once again? Sure. But so can any pitcher, despite age or toolbox.

If offered an option in between deGrom (entering his age-35 season), Verlander, and Rodon (entering his age-30 season), I’d pick deGrom quickly. He is just on another world. And I’m going to wager his injuries are mainly behind him.

But if deGrom leaves, I’m of the viewpoint that the Mets require another ace to change him. And I believe it would be an exceptionally simple call to target Verlander over Rodon.

APPEARANCE: Bruins, Penguins reveal jerseys for 2023 NHL Winter Classic

Previous article

NBA DFS: Top DraftKings, FanDuel everyday Fantasy basketball selects for Nov. 26 consist of Shai Gilgeous-Alexander

Next article

You may also like

More in Baseball


Comments are closed.